Name: Sunset Beach, Shelter Island
Address: 35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York State, 11965
Price range: US$596+
Rating: 8.2

58 photos

Sunset Beach Shelter Island Amenities photo

Sunset Beach Shelter Island Exterior photo

Book on our site

up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, 11965

Nestled on an idyllic beach

Great

8.2

8.7

/10

3.9

3.5

3-star beachfront hotel in Shelter Island

Amenities

Sunset Beach offers an outdoor swimming pool accompanied by a sun terrace, providing direct access to the beach for recreational activities. There is an on-site restaurant where guests can enjoy ocean views while dining. The hotel also hosts a private beach area featuring lounge chairs for relaxation.

Rooms

The hotel features spacious rooms equipped with kitchenettes and dining areas for convenience during stays. Guests can choose from a variety of accommodations, all designed to provide a comfortable experience. Each room offers air conditioning and flat-screen televisions.

Location

Situated right on Shelter Island, the hotel provides easy access to the serene beach known for its scenic views. Nearby attractions include Turtle Cove and the Shelter Island Lighthouse, both within a short walking distance. The location allows guests to explore the natural beauty of the surroundings.

Dining

The on-site restaurant offers a variety of dishes prepared with fresh ingredients, catering to diverse culinary preferences. Guests can enjoy meals inside or on the outdoor patio facing the beach. The dining experience accommodates breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Activities

Sunset Beach provides guests access to various beach activities such as kayaking and paddleboarding. The hotel can assist with arranging local tours and excursions for exploring the island. Evening entertainment options are available, contributing to a lively atmosphere during summer months.

Highlights

Location: Beachfront in Shelter Island

Rooms: Spacious with kitchenettes

Dining: On-site restaurant with ocean views

Activities: Beach activities and local tours

Must-do experiences

Kayak through the serene waters of Shelter Island's bay.
Taste the lobster rolls at the famous Sunset Beach restaurant.
Visit the Shelter Island Historical Society Museum for local history.
Stroll through the beautiful gardens at the Mashomack Preserve.
Catch a sunset at Sunset Beach for breathtaking waterfront views.

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

July 2026 - July 2027

Sun

Mon

Tue

Wed

Thu

Fri

Sat

July 2026

August 2026

September 2026

October 2026

November 2026

December 2026

January 2027

February 2027

March 2027

April 2027

May 2027

June 2027

Choose dates to see prices

Check-in/ Check-out

Facilities

Sunset Beach offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

General

Wi-Fi
Smoke detectors

Dining

Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area

Room features

Dressing area
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Hair dryer

Media

Flat-screen TV
Direct dial telephone
CD player
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Sunset Beach Location

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, 11965

Explore Shelter Island

Local Highlights Near Sunset Beach

Shelter Island Country Club

10 minutes' walk

Charming golf club with stunning views, ideal for golf enthusiasts. Offers a friendly atmosphere and seasonal events.

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

25 minutes' walk

Historical estate and educational farm offering guided tours. Unique gardening workshops and vibrant community events throughout the year.

Our Lady of the Isle Church

15 minutes' walk

Beautiful church known for its serene environment and stunning architecture. Offers a tranquil spot for reflection and photography.

Kayaking at Sunset Beach

3 minutes' walk

Enjoy serene kayaking experiences. Rentals available on-site; ideal for both novice and experienced adventurers.

Hiking at Mashomack Preserve

10 minutes' drive

Exploring beautiful trails with diverse wildlife. A tranquil escape, perfect for nature lovers and those seeking relaxation.

The Pridwin Restaurant

11 minutes' walk

Casual dining with stunning waterfront views. Specialties include seafood and farm-fresh ingredients. Reservations recommended.

Sunset Beach Restaurant

3 minutes' walk

Beachfront eatery with a vibrant ambiance. Known for tropical cocktails and fresh local seafood, making it a must-visit.

Shelter Island Community Theater

25 minutes' walk

Offers seasonal plays and performances. A cozy venue that showcases local talent and provides an engaging experience.

Live Music at Sunset Beach

3 minutes' walk

Enjoy vibrant live music events through the summer. Great atmosphere perfect for families and all ages, often featuring local artists.

Getting around

City Centre
Shelter Island 2 min · 400 ft
Airports
Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 127 min · 52.5 mi
Republic (FRG) 170 min · 70.2 mi

Want to see Exclusive Early Booking Rate?

Get exlusive rates right now!

Check Rates

Property information and rules

Check-in

from 16:00-23:59

Check-out

until 11 am

Guest Parking

Public parking is possible on site for free.

Internet

Wireless internet is available in the entire hotel for free.

Breakfast

A full breakfast is served and charges are applicable.

Pets

Pets are allowed on request.

Year renovated:

2010

Number of rooms:

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback about Sunset Beach from previous guests about their experience.

Review score

Based on 6 verified reviews

8.0 /10

Great

67 %

Recommend

No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.

Open reviews

Show more reviews

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.

Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Uptown Fredericton By Ihg

Fredericton, Canada

8.364 reviews

90 USD/night

Shelter Island House

Shelter Island Heights, United States

9.120 reviews

569 USD/night

The Pridwin Hotel

Shelter Island, United States

8.953 reviews

334 USD/night

Grand Lake Hotel

Lebanon, United States

7.6

95 USD/night

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Greenport, United States

9.7

698 USD/night

The Wall Street Hotel New York City

New York, United States

9.3126 reviews

686 USD/night

Doubletree By Hilton Mahwah

Mahwah, United States

6.958 reviews

101 USD/night

Marina Bay Cottages

Waterford, United States

8.7

Copper Beech Inn

Ivoryton, United States

7.888 reviews

179 USD/night

Cold Spring Hotel

Cold Spring, United States

8.538 reviews

261 USD/night

Residence Inn By Marriott Springfield Chicopee

Chicopee, United States

9.046 reviews

169 USD/night

The Hotel Maria

Westerly, United States

9.549 reviews

462 USD/night

Popular hotels all over the world

Find your perfect hotel stay today

8.0/10151 reviews

Doubletree By Hilton Chicago O'Hare Airport-Rosemont

Doubletree Rosemont

Rosemont, United States

200 metres from Donald E Stephens Convention Center, Free 24-hour airport transfers

View hotel

8.2/1077 reviews

Hotel Doubletree Suites By Hilton Mount Laurel Mount Laurel

Mount Laurel, United States

All-suite hotel, Warm chocolate chip cookie on check-in

View hotel

8.2/10126 reviews

Asbury Park Hotel

Asbury Park, United States

300 m to boardwalk and beach, Heated outdoor pool open year-round

View hotel

Hotel Bandar Lampung

98 Superior Rooms, 10 Suites Rooms

Vanvihar.toresort.com/

36 km from Somnath Temple, Pool with a view

Hotel Villa Excellance Beach And Wave Pool Resort

Wave pool, Water park

The Hilton Garden Inn San Diego Downtown/bayside, Ca San Diego Hotel

3 km from San Diego International Airport, 7 min walk to Maritime Museum of San Diego

Zen Hotel Hotel Cheaphotels.me

Beach access

Hotel Moxy Louisville Downtown Louisville

Historic Whiskey Row location, Zombie Taco on-site restaurant

The Courtyard By Marriott Inverness Airport Inverness Hotel

460 m from Inverness Airport, Modern rooms with triple-glazed windows

Hotelresort.com/hotel/mayfairhimalayanspa

Fitness centre, Outdoor swimming pool

Holiday Home Bodhiwoods Resorts Mahabalipuram

2 km from Mahabalipuram Beach, Outdoor swimming pool